RFLink herkent type sensor niet altijd juist

[mjj4791]

Ik gebruik nu een RFLink (versie 1.1 R44, Build8) on 433mhz signalen te ontvangen en sturen.

Ik ontvang een weerstation/sensor, welke niet altijd juist gedecodeerd wordt; het type van de sensor wordt meestal als een Tunex gerapporteerd, maar soms ook als een Xiron.
Aangezien het niet mijn sensor is, weet ik niet welke van beide het juiste type is....

Echter aangezien afgezien van het type, het adres/id wel hetzelfde is, en de waarden gelijk, is het aannemelijk dat het echt slechts om 1 device gaat....

De signalen die ik ontvang, heb ik toegevoegd in de volgende post...

Mjj

[mjj4791]

20;14;DEBUG;Pulses=511;Pulses(uSec)=420,3840,360,1860,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,930,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1860,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1860,390,3840,360,1890,390,900,360,1890,390,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,1860,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,3840,360,1890,390,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1860,390,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,1860,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1890,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,1890,390,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,390,1860,360,1860,390,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,1860,360,1890,390,900,390,900,360,1860,390,3840,360,1890,360,900,390,1860,390,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,1860,390,1860,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,360,1890,390,900,390,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,3840,360,1860,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,1380,360,1860,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,900,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,390,1860,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,3840,360,1860,390,900,360,1860,390,900,360,1860,360,1890,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1860,390;
20;15;Tunex;ID=AF02;TEMP=00d0;HUM=25;BAT=OK;
20;16;DEBUG;Pulses=511;Pulses(uSec)=420,3840,390,1860,360,900,360,1860,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1890,390,1860,360,900,390,900,360,1860,360,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,900,360,900,390,1890,360,900,390,900,360,900,390,900,390,1860,360,1860,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,900,390,900,360,900,360,1860,360,1890,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,3840,360,1890,390,900,360,1860,390,900,360,1860,360,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,390,900,360,900,360,1860,360,900,360,900,390,900,390,900,360,1890,360,1890,390,900,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,1890,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,1860,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,1860,390,3840,360,1860,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1890,390,870,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1890,360,1890,360,900,390,1890,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,3840,360,1860,390,900,360,1860,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,390,900,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,390,1860,360,1260,480,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1890,390,1860,360,900,360,900,360,1860,360,3840,360,1860,360,900,360,1860,390,900,390,1860,390,1860,360,1860,360,1860,390,1890,360,900,360,900,360,1860,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360;
20;17;Tunex;ID=AF02;TEMP=00d0;HUM=25;BAT=OK;

[mjj4791]

20;66;DEBUG;Pulses=511;Pulses(uSec)=420,840,330,1800,330,1860,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,3840,360,1860,390,900,360,1860,390,900,360,1860,390,1890,390,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,1410,360,1860,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1890,390,1890,360,900,390,900,360,1890,360,3840,360,1860,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,390,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,1860,390,900,390,900,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,1890,390,900,390,900,360,1890,360,1890,390,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,390,1890,360,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,390,1860,360,900,390,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,390,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1860,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1860,390,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,390,900,390,1860,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,900,390,900,390,900,360,900,390,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,390,900,360,900,360,870,390,1860,360,1860,360,900,390,900,360,1890,390,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,1890,390,1890,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,1890,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,1890,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,390,1890,360,1860,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,390,1890,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,3840,360,1890,360,900,390,1860,360,900,360,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,1890,390,1890,360,900,390,900,360;
20;67;Xiron;ID=AF04;TEMP=00cf;HUM=25;BAT=OK;
20;49;DEBUG;Pulses=511;Pulses(uSec)=420,1800,360,3630,330,1800,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,900,360,900,390,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,360,900,360,1860,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1860,360,900,360,1860,360,1890,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,900,390,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,1890,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,1890,390,3840,360,1860,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,1890,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,900,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,1890,390,1890,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,900,360,900,390,1890,360,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,1890,360,900,390,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,1890,390,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,3840,360,1890,390,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,1380,390,1860,390,900,360,900,390,900,390,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,1890,390,1890,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,360,900,360,900,390,1890,360,3840,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1860,360,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,900,390,900,360,1890,360,900,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,1860,390,1860,360,1890,360,1860,390,1890,360,1890,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,900,360,1860,390,1860,390,900,360,900,360,1890,360,3840,360,1890,390,900,360,1890,360,900,360,1890,360,1890,390,1890,360,1860,360,1890,360,900,360,900,390,1860,360,900,390,900,360,900,360,900,390,1830,420,1860,360,900,360,900,360,1890,390,1890,360,1890,360,1860,360,1890,390,1890,360,1890,360,1860,390,900,360,900,390,900,390;
20;4A;Xiron;ID=AF02;TEMP=00cf;HUM=25;BAT=OK;

[Stuntteam]

Oke, bedankt!
Als de ID gelijk is, geeft het verder geen probleem. De naam is slechts een label.

[mjj4791]

Helder; ik begrijp waar je vandaan komt;
Misschien even wat context....

Ik heb een werkende python library voor RFLink die nu switches, lights en sensoren ondersteunt.
Om de devices uniek te kunnen aanduiden, geef ik ze een unieke id. Ik gebruik de naam/type, het id en eventueel het switch-nummer om een unieke id te genereren voor een switch/lamp/sensor. Nu dat de naam wisselt, heb ik ineens 2 sensoren (in plaats van 1)...
Vandaar de vraag.

Voor een sensor kan ik er nog inkomen dat de naam/type optioneel is, je hoeft nl nooit een commando te sturen naar een sensor (voor switches/lampen, etc. zou dat anders zijn). Het is echter mogelijk dat twee verschillende sensoren (van verschillend type), hetzelfde adres hebben. Als ik in dat geval de naam/type niet meeneem om het id te genereren, krijgen twee sensoren hetzelfde id... dat is een het omgekeerde (en vervelender) probleem...

Dank voor de feedback!